Separation of Professional and Personal Space?
Last evening, I contemplated the merits of maintaining two separate blogs: A professional edublog, and a second, more personal blog. Especially given my recent illness, I wasn’t sure if visitors, both new and returning, desired to read about my struggles on a blog which professed to be about teaching and learning.
But, at what point don’t the professional and personal blur, overlap, and intersect in our lives? Or, when one takes over the other for a period of time? I am not really able to speak on the professional right now, expressly because I have not been at school in over a week. My absence from the workplace has created a shortfall of authentic material. However, there is no shortfall of personal material. Therefore, for the sake of authenticity, I draw more heavily on the personal for the meantime.
There are many in the blogosphere, perhaps even some of you who visit from time to time, who maintain two blogs for the express purpose of keeping the professional and the personal separate and uncluttered. First, I respect that. Second, I admire any person who is able to maintain two or more blogs simultaneously. Blogging is a lot of work! And yet, there is a certain charm in those blogs, mine included, which, whether intentionally or by default, create a sort of patchwork quilt by merging the professional and the personal. The subject matter may be unpredictable, and the direction not easily navigable, but the voice clear, true and authentic. I also find myself sometimes feeling really conflicted regarding the subject matter of my posts: Does this really speak to who I am as a teacher?
This is not to say that one who separates the professional and the personal via the maintenance of two separate blogs is not clear, true and authentic in his/her voice on both accounts. Superkimbo/mscofino demonstrates these three characterstics beautifully in her two blogs, Follow That Elephant! and Always Learning. What I am saying is when one has a blog which blends the professional and the personal, there seems to be more self-editing at times for the sake of professional purity. Or, at least this is how I feel sometimes in my blogging life.
As I conclude this post, I am obviously no closer to an answer re: the separation of professional and personal space than when I began. This being said, I am more inclined to maintaining one blog. However, perhaps you, the reader can weigh in: Are there advantages to maintaining two blogs for the purpose of separating the professional and the personal? And, if you or someone you know maintains two separate blogs for this purpose, what benefits and challenges have you/he/she encountered?
Loading...
Excellent questions, Miss Profe! First, thank you for saying such nice things about my blogs
I love that you read both of them! It can be a hassle having two (plus my classroom blog for the students), but I’m having so much fun, it’s hard to resist!
Now, to answer your questions:
I guess I made a conscious decision at the begining to keep two seperate blogs. I never really had a concrete rationale, but, in retrospect, I would say I did it for the following reasons:
- I figured that people who want to know about my teaching may not be as interested in pictures of my wedding or my holidays or stories about my family and friends (and vice versa) - some of these things, sure, but probably not all topics, all the time.
- I do think there are some things I just don’t talk about at work - with students, parents, colleagues, or administrators. I figured that I would want to keep those kinds of things out of the realm of my professional life, just like I do in person.
- I thought it might be easier for me to write if I had a focus, a specific audience.
All in all I would say I’m happy with my decision. I like having a little more “fun” on my personal blog, and although there is some overlap in readership, I enjoy trying to see things from different perspectives. I love having different groups of people that I communicate with online. I love having all my thoughts so well organized and easy to share with other people. I actually really enjoy being able to seperate these two aspects of my life.
Having said that, lately I’ve felt like I should put a little more “superkimbo” into the Always Learning blog. I do feel that my professional blog isn’t totally representative of my personality because I’m always making a concerted effort to stay focused on the professional. Sometimes this does bother me - and that’s when we end up with somewhat silly posts like Off to work we go! Sometimes I’m just not sure how far to go…
One other disadvantage to having two blogs is that I think I often “use up” my thoughts/energy/excitement writing on my personal blog. I tend to post there every day, which means I post quite a bit less to my professional blog. I’m not sure there is enough time in the day to post to both as regularly as I would like!
Thanks for getting me thinking about this again. I’ve gotten into the groove of two, but I definitely find that I love reading personal bits in your blog (and others). Adding those personal stories helps readers understand the whole person, and provides a more well-rounded vision of the author.
superkimbo - February 17, 2007 at 11:23 am
missprofe,
Good to see that you are recovering from you bout with the flu. I did read through your posts and, as I’ve said, I think that you do a find job of combining the personal and the public. However, if you were wanting to explore personal things in a deepr context, a second blog might be in order. I’ve actually been thinking of this for myself - somewhere to just explore some of my more personal ideas and feelings. The time factor is what is stopping me at this point. I’m hoping that I’ll find time, eventually, to do some more personal blog exploring that is outside the education realm. I agree that, as a teacher, the lines really blur between personal and school. Sometimes it is difficult where one stops and the other begins.
Happy belated Valentine’s Day!!
Kelly Christopherson - February 17, 2007 at 11:57 am
I only maintain the one blog, but as I am no longer at work, I have no conflict as you are describing. In such a case I can see the merits of having the two.
I always enjoy reading your post and hope if you do set up a second you would consider allowing me to read it.
Bill
hudds53 - February 17, 2007 at 6:33 pm
I hope you feel better. I
‘d love to see how you resolve the blog issue.I don’t know I still like the first one. I thought it was very indie cool.
I myself paint. So the time issue is so true.You’d blog a lot to run two. I find your blog true to the statement of “keeping it real”.
One thing I was interested in doing is keeping it sarah. Whatever that means.
As I am an artist I try things, make mistakes, create, follow lines of thought, bumble. I need a few days off to figure out links and this and that technologically which you do so nicely. But I wanted for awhile this dark colored blog that would be A Night In the Life where I could be less teacher and more artist-edgier, maybe even talk about cancer and fears, talk about difficult peer interactions, talk about things making me mad….but I decided to journal that and to use this thing I’m doing as I originally thought I would. To share out on school and life. Speak to the difficulties in teaching with NCLB issues seemingly making it harder. well I was placing pieces with Susan Ohanian on her site and decided to blog too.(she is so awesome)
Not that that means toast by way of help on this. I hope to see how you deal with it all including the design. . Hope you are feeling better and resting. Sarah
Sarah Puglisi - February 17, 2007 at 11:38 pm
Now everything is better.
I like the black background.
It places you “there” for me.
I know…hard for some to see maybe…but then…I got white blind. I like reading on dark surface. But for me…this is how I see you.
I like it.
I read some study about avatars that people use in chatrooms. Something about how changing them caused emotional …upset-ness? Well anyway it was all about how that simple thing stood symbolically as a “representation’ to the readers. Now if I could only find that. It was interesting. Reminding me of Doug’s symbol stuff.
Sarah Puglisi - February 18, 2007 at 12:12 pm
I maintain two blogs but both have a professional basis for the majority of their content. Teaching Generation Z is MY blog where I detail my own professional learning while the other Activboarding is provided more as a service to others. I take much more pride in the former and would be devastated if edublogs fell over tomorrow and everything disappeared. I am much less attached and more dispassionate about the latter - it shows in the style of writing that I use as well. Two blogs are extra work and inevitably, one may suffer at the expense of the other. My advice? Discount guessing what your audience might prefer as they usually read you for your unique mix of personal and professional - taking out that element of uniqueness or altering its organic balance could defeat the purpose of the blog for its main reader - YOU!
Graham Wegner - February 18, 2007 at 9:48 pm
Well missprofe,
I’ve crashed and burned and melded and diversified and consolidated and dumped then re-born and split and rekindled and fired-up and deleted and started and finished and and and.
I dont see any difference between one and the other. I am of the firm opinion that it’s not about connectivisim rather about life based action learning with a smattering of psychological flattening and the odd rant to boot.
Why have two when you can as many as you like ? In fact if you were to have a blog with every free provider that you could find then you’d have what equates to what that Rise of The Machines Youtube video was on about.
Or…….if your as clever as other educators who teach us how the machine reads and see’s then you could be building linkblogs such as Sean Fitzgerald - http://del.icio.us/seanfitz/mylinkblog
A very cool idea. Perhaps we could have Flickr blogs and Blogline’s blogs and and and.
Cant wait to see what your third blog will involve
Alexander Hayes - February 21, 2007 at 5:24 am
[...] complement what missprofe was speaking of [9:50:45 PM] Alexander Hayes says: the link of hers at [edited] [9:50:58 PM] Graham Wegner says: right [9:51:10 PM] Graham Wegner says: She’s a pretty cool [...]
missprofe : Blogging Paradigms or e-Ciphering in Lagtime : alexanderhayes - September 2, 2007 at 6:52 am